menu
Weekly Online Magazine
ISSN 2544-5839
zamknij
Media Review image

8.01.2024 Media industry

Information bubbles. Study of Instagram, Tik Tok and You Tube users

Urszula Kaczorowska, PAP Science in Poland

A staggering 96 percent of the time people spend online is spent on anything but consuming information. This, says Professor Magdalena Wojcieszak means ‘we have over-inflated the issue of information bubbles and disinformation.’
Poczytaj artykuł wydanie polskie w wydaniu polskim

We have over-inflated the issue of information bubblesilustracja: bing.com/create

In November, Professor Wojcieszak from the University of California at Davis (USA) and the University of Warsaw received the prestigious ERC Consolidator grant of EUR 2 million. For five years, she will study the consumption of news media by Instagram, Tik Tok and YouTube users in the USA, Poland, Spain and England. Volunteers willing to take part in the study will install a tool in their applications that generates frequent display of social and political news. Wojcieszak will check how this will affect their views and online activity over time.

The researcher has previously carried out projects on the behaviour of Internet users in the USA, the Netherlands and Poland. The results of her work were published in such prestigious journals as Science and Nature.

Wojcieszak`s analysis shows that 7,300 users observed for 9 months generated 106 million visits to various websites. Just over 3 percent of these were visits to news media websites, and most of them were not looking for information on social and political topics. Much more often, they wanted to check sports results, the weather, or how to cook a specific dish.

The problem of low consumption of social and political information is also visible on social media. This is partly due to the intentional actions of the owners of these companies. According to a report by Meta, the owner of Facebook, before 2018, the annual share of content from news media on this website reached 4.0%. After changing the algorithm, in 2022 this share dropped to 1.4%.


`My research results published in Nature show that only 6% of the content that Facebook users see on their profiles concerns social and political news (including the content of funny memes and reels). And only half of that content is consistent with their beliefs. It is easy to see that we have over-inflated the issue of information bubbles and disinformation,’ Wojcieszak says.

`Of course,’ she adds, ‘even a small group of users can have an impact on social life. An example is the attack on the United States Capitol in January 2021. But what puzzles me most is the overwhelming group of users who do not consume social and political content. Do they not click on it because it is presented in an unattractive way? Or because they do not believe that this knowledge has any impact on their lives?

In a study conducted on You Tube, Wojcieszak found that users did not pay any attention to regularly appearing banners with the following content: `reading the news influences your financial decisions` and `reading the news influences the quality of democracy in your country`.

However, when a special IT tool added content from the news media to the `watched history`, this content automatically appeared more often in the recommended column. Then users started to watch it and, interestingly, this did not reduce the time of their activity on the website.

`In 2018, Mark Zuckerberg changed Facebook`s algorithm to limit content shared by the media in favour of content from friends and family. The idea was to give people a platform to enjoy. This was probably due to the fact that social media managers were afraid that if users encountered social and political content too often, their activity time on the website would decrease, which would result in a decrease in revenues from advertisers. My research on the YouTube platform shows that this is not true,’ says Wojcieszak.

The researcher is convinced that social media users need to be encouraged to consume social and political information. She hopes that the results of her research will be noticed by media managers `who will finally stop repeating ad nauseum that people want to read and watch content that is light, easy and pleasant or sensational and polarizing`.

SELF PROMOTION. Got a minute? Find out our #59sec REPORT on Youtube

`Only 3 out of 10 consumed social and political materials come from the websites of media publishers. Maybe media managers will come to terms with the fact that perhaps a significant part of the public does not react to information content because it is presented in a wrong way. Maybe they will invest in a study measuring the Internet users` profile that drives all traffic in their media,’ Wojcieszak says.

She adds that she counts on the procedural support of the European Union.

`The grant is financed by the European Union, which regulates social media activities to a much better extent than the United States. Maybe I will be able to spark a debate on possible pressure on the heads of platforms to establish close cooperation with the media and require them to post more social and political content from reliable sources on their websites,’ Wojcieszak adds.

Professor Wojcieszak is a recipient of the ERC Starting Grant held at the University of Amsterdam, and has authored more than 80 publications in peer-reviewed journals. She serves as an editor of the Journal of Communication, and is a member of the editorial boards of seven peer-reviewed journals. Wojcieszak’s awards include the Young Scholar Award from the International Communication Association. This year, in recognition of her outstanding scientific achievements, she was elected ICA Fellow at the International Communication Association.

source: PAP Science in Poland

Share the article:

dodaj na Facebook prześlij przez Messenger dodaj na Twitter dodaj na LinkedIn

COMMERCIAL BREAK
Work In Media

New articles in section Media industry

Trust in social media. Youtube beats TikTok and X

Krzysztof Fiedorek
Do we really trust social media? A new study reveals major differences in how top platforms are rated. Trust goes where there's authenticity, not just algorithms. The role of people is growing while brand influence is fading.

Artificial intelligence in newsrooms. Three realities of the AI era in media

Krzysztof Fiedorek
According to a report by the European Broadcasting Union, many newsrooms already use AI but still do not fully trust it. Audiences do not want "robotic" news, and the technologies themselves though fast can be costly, unreliable, and surprisingly human in their mistakes.

Zero-click search 2025. The even bigger end of clicking in search engines

Bartłomiej Dwornik
Google is giving up its role as a web signpost. More and more, it wants to be the destination of the whole journey. ChatGPT and Perplexity are hot on its heels, changing the rules of the search game. AI Overviews is a card from the same deck. Only content creators are losing ground in this race.


See articles on a similar topic:

Repression Against Media: Committee to Protect Journalists Report for 2024

Krzysztof Fiedorek
In 2024, at least 361 journalists worldwide were imprisoned, often for exposing the truth. In China, reporters are tracked using advanced facial recognition systems, in Israel, Palestinian journalists are jailed without trial, and in Myanmar, journalist Shin Daewe received a life sentence for... a drone.

Algorithmic personalization study. Who and how understands digital media

KFi
Most internet users believe that everyone sees the same content online. Meanwhile, algorithms personalize messages so effectively that a young woman with higher education receives different information than her father. Researchers reveal who truly understands the mechanisms.

Media Subscriptions to Replace Advertising. TMT Predictions 2018

BARD
Some publishers already consider attempts to generate revenue from online advertising a waste of time. According to the "TMT Predictions 2018" report by Deloitte, by the end of 2018, half of all adults in developed countries will have at least two online media subscriptions.

Influencers 2024. Data, Facts, and Stories from the UNESCO Report

Krzysztof Fiedorek
As many as 68% of digital creators are nano-influencers. One in three has experienced hate speech, and over 60% do not thoroughly verify information before publishing. Moreover, only half disclose their content sponsors. The findings from the "Behind The Screens" report are both inspiring and alarming.

More in the section: Media industry

community

Facebook LinkedIn X Twitter TikTok Instagram Threads Youtube Google News Blue Sky Social RSS

Reporterzy.info - online media studies magazine. The world of communication from the inside. Media, journalism, PR and marketing. Data, reports, analyses, advice. History and market, law, photography, job offers.


Work in media

United States
New York • Washington DC • Los Angeles • Chicago • Houston • Phoenix • Philadelphia United Kingdom
London • Birmingham • Manchester • Liverpool • Glasgow • Edinburgh Canada
Toronto • Ottawa • Montreal • Calgary Australia
Sydney • Melbourne • Brisbane • canberra Ireland, New Zealand, India

advertisement

Flying Tiger





Reporter shopping

Reporter shopping

Affordable laptops, notebooks and netbooks
Affordable laptops, notebooks and netbooks
for writing
Digital SLR and compact cameras
Digital SLR and compact cameras
for photographers
Books and e-books about media
Books and e-books about media
for reading
Video drones and flying cameras
Video drones and flying cameras
for pilots
Gimbals for stabilizing video
Gimbals for stabilizing video
for those on the move
Software and apps for creative work
Software and apps for creative work
for digital creators
More occasions

follow us 👉 on Youtube
Watch more 👇
#4Lines 4 a Good(?) Morning SHORTS
Read books and e-books

Read books and e-books

Okładka The 40-Day Social Media Fast
The 40-Day Social Media Fast
Okładka Social Media Marketing All-in-One For Dummies
Social Media Marketing All-in-One For Dummies
Okładka Mass Communication: Living in a Media World
Mass Communication: Living in a Media World
Okładka Beyond The Feed: A Social Media Success Formula
Beyond The Feed: A Social Media Success Formula
Okładka Trust Me, I`m Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator
Trust Me, I`m Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator
Okładka Hate, Inc.: Why Today`s Media Makes Us Despise One Another
Hate, Inc.: Why Today`s Media Makes Us Despise One Another
more books and e-books

Reporterzy.info

More about us

Our tools and services

Contact


© Dwornik.pl Bartłomiej Dwornik 2oo1-2o25