menu
Weekly Online Magazine
ISSN 2544-5839
zamknij
MediaHisttory Podcast image

7.07.2025 Skills and knowledge

A heuristic trap in media coverage. How loud headlines boost fear

Bartłomiej Dwornik

A negative message that rests on emotion lifts the sense of threat by 57%. Why do reports of a plane crash drive investors away from airline shares. Why do flood stories spark worry about the next deluge. The pattern is irrational yet clear and proven.
Poczytaj artykuł wydanie polskie w wydaniu polskim

A heuristic trap in media coverage. How loud headlines boost fearillustration: DALL-E

Experiments by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky in the 1970s showed that people overrate events they recall with ease. Since then media watchers have noted that the same mental shortcut bites still harder today amid vast information noise. This effect is called availability heuristic. It leads to many risky cognitive slips.

Rui Feng from Tianjin University analysed 1600 disaster news stories and proved that the rate of media mentions lifts risk ratings more than official death counts. The more coverage, the faster the belief that danger lurks round the corner.


Digital media act like a megaphone. One click starts a share cascade and the headline sticks like a splinter. As a result our sense of safety shifts faster than real conditions. A simple chain shows how the availability heuristic grows:

  • intense message means more exposure to information
  • more exposure means higher credibility in the eyes of readers
  • higher credibility means an inflated risk estimate

So a short circuit links memory with prediction and steers later choices.

Fear works harder. Almost double


Joel W. Roberts and team at the University of Texas at Arlington tested in 2024 how emotion changes the power of the heuristic. Volunteers saw extreme negative and extreme positive event scripts. The first set raised the judged chance of an accident or illness.

A shock message acts like a memory booster. When the item shocks, the brain writes it in bold and risk climbs in the mind. A bright extreme gave no such push. Joy seems to fade sooner than fear. The impact appears in numbers:

Stimulus Mean shift in perceived probability
Extreme negative +57%
Extreme positive +34%
Neutral +31%


The negative cue nearly doubled expected risk versus the neutral sample. In practice tabloids and dramatic reports not only stir emotion but also rescale the audience’s maths.

Weakening factors. The authors list three. Topic saturation. Cool expert commentary. Breaks in exposure. Short pauses cut the effect by one third.

Fresh empirical evidence


Northern and Southern Europe differ in climate yet share the same shortcut. Giacomo Di Baldassarre and co-workers surveyed more than 8000 Italians and Swedes during 2019-2021. People who had just faced a flood, avalanche or health crisis showed the highest fear level for the same hazard ahead.

MediaHisttory Podcast
The pandemic added another layer. At the peak of the second COVID-19 wave respondents ranked the virus as fiercer than quakes or fires, though geology sometimes killed more. Fresh experience beat dry data.

The study revealed three tiers of availability:

  • personal experience raises subjective risk the most
  • media coverage works likewise but fades after a week
  • exact victim count has a mild effect unless it sets a record

A note for reporters. Each post-disaster story heightens public readiness for the next blow even when odds fall year by year.

Risk costs. Real money


Financiers also bow to the heuristic. A 2025 study by Xike Lei of Chongqing College of Economics tracked private investors on five emerging markets in 2023-2024. The author showed that a mention of a plane crash cut airline shares in portfolios by 18% within 24 hours despite no firm news on the carriers.

Investors moved faster when the news arrived by video than by text. Women shifted cash to deposits while men raised commodity stakes. The gender gap reached 11 percentage points against high-risk stocks.

Media event Change in high-risk share holding Women’s move Men’s move
Plane crash (video) −18% −22% −14%
Stock crash (text) −9% −11% −7%


The table shows how the idea of a rare drama flows straight into money moves. When availability rises, data-based maths yields to emotion.

The study offers two counterpaths. Lift economic and market education. Set rules for alarmist messages on finance sites. Both aim to trim the gap between real and felt risk.

Distortions and cognitive errors can be minimised


How can we blunt mental shortcuts and slips. Jairigis Hodson’s team at Canada’s Royal Roads University reviewed outreach campaigns from the first two pandemic years and coined ‘reasoned transparency’, meaning thoughtful openness. Experts urge us to explain uncertainty rather than hide it under false certainty.

The model has three steps. First, the author states what is known. Next, they clarify what is unknown and why the gap exists. Last, they say when new data may arrive. The reader then treats news as a process, not a verdict.

SELF PROMOTION. Got a minute? Find out our #59sec REPORT on Youtube

The strongest tools named by the scholars:

  • comparison of case counts to population not to a headline
  • display of a trend chart not a single anecdote
  • prompt for self-calculation via interactive tools

Each tool cut false belief rates by 15-20% within a week. The aim is not to quench emotion but to shift it from fear to curiosity. Reasoned transparency seeks not to fight the heuristic but to guide a healthier use of memory.

The availability heuristic is quick fuel for our imagination, yet it need not rule every decision. It is not a brain flaw but its fast mode. The media know how to spark it because a sharp rise in attention turns into ad gold. When you see another "breaking news" banner, do a simple test. Am I judging risk by the picture or by the data? If the picture wins, pause, check the numbers, and then choose.

Share the article:

dodaj na Facebook prześlij przez Messenger dodaj na Twitter dodaj na LinkedIn

COMMERCIAL BREAK
Work In Media

New articles in section Skills and knowledge

How LLMs are reshaping SEO. Smart content strategies for the age of AI

BDw
For years, SEO was a fairly predictable game. Pick the right keywords, optimize your content, and watch your website climb the rankings. But today, a silent revolution is underway - and it`s being led by large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and DeepSeek.

Chronemics, or The Language of Time. What Your Watch Says About You

Bartłomiej Dwornik
You walk in on time, glance at your watch, wait five minutes, then leave. Someone else is thirty minutes late and acts like they had to wait for you. Time in communication is a tool, a weapon, and a status marker. Welcome to the world of chronemics. The study of how time affects human relationships.

Preschoolers Expose Hypocrites. Findings from SWPS University

ekr/ bar/
Even preschool children are able to recognize hypocrites, whom they rate worse than other people who break the rules, researchers from SWPS University in Poland demonstrate. Caregivers should therefore pay attention to whether their actions are consistent with their declarations, because children are careful observers of moral integrity.


See articles on a similar topic:

How Information is Created?

Agnieszka Osińska
The media construct the world for us - the audience. However, most viewers, listeners, or readers do not have direct access to the issues discussed in the reports.

How to Write an Article That Google Loves and People Understand

Bartłomiej Dwornik
The order of priorities in this guide's title is intentional. In 2024, to reach a larger audience, you must first convince the algorithms to display your content to readers. First - the article must be factually sound. Second - it should look appealing and be easy to read. We’ll focus on the latter.

Video, Photo, or Text? What Really Works in Social Campaigns

KFi
Can ecology go viral? How can complex environmental issues be communicated in an engaging and effective way? A study by Wenye Mao and Yuko Nishide from Tohoku University analyzes two elements of narrative strategy: the type of medium (posts, posters, videos) and the mode of storytelling (individual vs. group).

AI slops and microtargeting. Why wou should NOT LIKE the bread horse

Bartłomiej Dwornik
"I grew this garlic chive all by myself on the windowsill. But I bet you won't congratulate me." Do you also see an influx of such posts in online communities? Be careful. This is called AI slop (or Boomer Trap), and it is NOT just a harmless game or entertainment. It is a well-thought-out mechanism in which the currency is you. First, your time and engagement. And soon, your money.

More in the section: Skills and knowledge

community

Facebook LinkedIn X Twitter TikTok Instagram Threads Youtube Google News Blue Sky Social RSS

Reporterzy.info - online media studies magazine. The world of communication from the inside. Media, journalism, PR and marketing. Data, reports, analyses, advice. History and market, law, photography, job offers.


Work in media

United States
New York • Washington DC • Los Angeles • Chicago • Houston • Phoenix • Philadelphia United Kingdom
London • Birmingham • Manchester • Liverpool • Glasgow • Edinburgh Canada
Toronto • Ottawa • Montreal • Calgary Australia
Sydney • Melbourne • Brisbane • canberra Ireland, New Zealand, India

advertisement

Media Review 24/7





Reporter shopping

Reporter shopping

Affordable laptops, notebooks and netbooks
Affordable laptops, notebooks and netbooks
for writing
Digital SLR and compact cameras
Digital SLR and compact cameras
for photographers
Books and e-books about media
Books and e-books about media
for reading
Video drones and flying cameras
Video drones and flying cameras
for pilots
Gimbals for stabilizing video
Gimbals for stabilizing video
for those on the move
Software and apps for creative work
Software and apps for creative work
for digital creators
More occasions

follow us 👉 on Youtube
Watch more 👇
#59sec REPORT SHORTS
Read books and e-books

Read books and e-books

Okładka Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man
Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man
Okładka Media Control. The Spectacular Achievements of Propaganda
Media Control. The Spectacular Achievements of Propaganda
Okładka The 40-Day Social Media Fast
The 40-Day Social Media Fast
Okładka Social Media Marketing All-in-One For Dummies
Social Media Marketing All-in-One For Dummies
Okładka Mass Communication: Living in a Media World
Mass Communication: Living in a Media World
Okładka Trust Me, I`m Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator
Trust Me, I`m Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator
more books and e-books

Reporterzy.info

More about us

Our tools and services

Contact


© Dwornik.pl Bartłomiej Dwornik 2oo1-2o25