22.01.2024 Skills and knowledge
Betteridge's Law: Is Every Headline with a Question Mark a Gimmick?
Krzysztof Fiedorek
Betteridge's Law is a journalism hypothesis suggesting that any headline ending with a question mark can be answered with “no.” This rule applies to yes-or-no questions. It wasn’t actually created by Ian Betteridge and… it’s mostly untrue.
The hypothesis about question marks in titles is called Betteridge`s Law, Betteridge`s Rule, or Betteridge`s Principle. It was formulated by British journalist Ian Betteridge in a February 23, 2009 article on Technovia.co.uk. Analyzing an article from TechCrunch, Betteridge noted that headlines ending with a question mark are often untrue or misleading.
Titles are often crafted this way to catch readers’ attention or create a sense of sensationalism. They imply that something important or disturbing has happened, like scientists discovering a new cancer cure or the government planning new taxes, even if there’s no confirmation for such claims.
The Question Mark in Titles: Why Do They Do It?
Betteridge’s hypothesis is widely accepted by journalists and scholars. It’s used to assess the credibility of headlines, suggesting that headlines ending in a question mark should be treated with caution. However, the use of question marks in titles is more complex. Often, the goal is to grab readers’ attention or create intrigue, rather than to convey accurate information.
- Capturing Reader Attention
A question mark can draw the reader’s attention, enticing them to read the article. Headlines with question marks are often mysterious, sensational, or alarming, hinting at important or interesting information. Example: Will Artificial Intelligence Replace Humans at Work? - Highlighting Information Importance
A question mark can emphasize the importance of the information in the article. Headlines with question marks often imply that the article presents significant or controversial information. Example: Are COVID-19 Vaccines Safe? - Evoking Emotion
A question mark can evoke emotions like curiosity, surprise, or concern in the reader. Question-marked headlines are often emotionally charged, suggesting that there’s a surprise or shocking information in the article. Example: Will Global Warming Lead to Humanity`s Demise? - Delivering Information
A question mark can make information more engaging and interesting. Headlines with question marks are often more memorable than those without. Example: Do You Know How Long Cells Live in Your Body? - Legal Safeguarding
A question mark is sometimes used as legal protection, for example, against defamation claims. Posing a question rather than stating a fact can be used as a defense. Example: Did Politician X Embezzle Public Funds?
Betteridge`s Law applies to yes-or-no questions, suggesting caution when encountering question-marked headlines.
Marr, Hinchliffe, Davis: Was Betteridge the First?
While Ian Betteridge is credited with formulating the law on headlines, other authors noted this tendency before him. In 2004, British journalist Andrew Marr mentioned it in his book My Trade:
When a headline poses a question, consider answering no. Is this a true depiction of British youth? A sensible reader might answer ‘no’. Have we discovered a cure for AIDS? No; if so, the question mark would not be there. Does this map hold the key to peace? Probably not. In most cases, a headline ending with a question mark suggests the article is biased or exaggerated. It aims to scare or amplify a simple fact into a controversy, or even a national panic. For journalists seeking accurate information, a question mark means ‘waste of time’.
In the 1980s, physicist Ian Hinchliffe proposed a similar idea, leading to what is known in the academic world as Hinchliffe’s Rule. He noted that if a scientific article’s title is a yes-or-no question, the answer will likely be "no." This principle inspired a humorous take on the liar paradox in a 1988 paper by physicist Boris Kayser, under the pseudonym “Boris Peon,” titled: “Is Hinchliffe`s Principle True?”
The principle of question marks in headlines is also known as Davis’s Law, appearing under this name in 1990s literature. It’s even mentioned in the English Wikipedia, though without a source on Davis`s identity or origin.
Does Betteridge`s Law Hold True?
The key question is whether the principle of answering "no" to headline questions is… actually true. Or to what extent it holds up. Research and analyses show that the world isn’t strictly binary in this regard.
- In 2016, James Cook and Dawn Ploudre published in "Scientometrics" a study of scientific journals (not news publications) to test Betteridge’s Law and Hinchliffe`s Rule. The study found that few titles posed questions, and even fewer were yes-or-no questions, with the answer more often "yes" in the article than "no".
- A 2018 study by John Moli at the University of California, Davis, covering 2,585 articles in four ecology journals, also found few titles posed questions, with only 2.15% being yes-or-no questions. Of those, 44% answered "yes," 34% "maybe," and only 22% "no".
- In 2015, data analyst Mats Linander analyzed 26,000 articles from 13 online news sites and published his findings on his blog. The study showed that most (almost 54%) were yes-or-no questions, with approximately 20% answering "yes," 17% "no," and 16% "maybe".
The conclusion from these analyses is clear. In most cases, the rule of answering "no" to question-marked headlines doesn’t hold up. Whether called Betteridge’s Law, Davis’s Law, or Hinchliffe’s Rule, its existence points to a real issue: journalistic misuse, which frequently appears here.
So when you see a question mark at the end of a headline in a newspaper or on a website: BEWARE! There’s no certainty, but statistically, there’s a strong probability that such a sensational title is just clickbait.
COMMERCIAL BREAK
See articles on a similar topic:
Psychology of Politics: Extremism
Krzysztof Dowgird
The term "extremist," according to the dictionary definition, refers to "a person with extreme views, a radical, an advocate of extreme, ultimate measures." In relation to political extremism, this means, first, views of an extreme nature (including approval for the use of force to solve political problems).
On TikTok, Music Rules. Three Tips from an Expert on How to Leverage It
BRM
Music dominates TikTok – more specifically, well-chosen music, as it often determines the success of a video, educational campaign, or advertisement. How should a company select music for TikTok content? Tips from Wojciech Psiuk, music supervisor from Sirens.
Max Weber's Theory of Political Sociology
Krzysztof Dowgird
Max Weber, a German sociologist who lived from 1864 to 1920, was undoubtedly the greatest non-Marxist sociologist of political relations. He had a tremendous and enduring impact on many branches of social sciences, including the sociology of political relations.
Sarcasm in Communication. A Study by INSEAD Researchers
Krzysztof Fiedorek
Sarcasm can be a valuable tool in interpersonal communication, but its effectiveness depends on the context and the relationship between the sender and the receiver. Researchers at INSEAD have shown that well-utilized sarcasm can be a powerful asset in business language and advertising.
Writing for the Web: The 4x4 Rule for Content Optimization
Bartłomiej Dwornik
How do you craft a Google-friendly title, what’s the ideal article length, and how often should you use keywords? A guide for those writing for websites.
How to Write an Article That Google Loves and People Understand
Bartłomiej Dwornik
The order of priorities in this guide's title is intentional. In 2024, to reach a larger audience, you must first convince the algorithms to display your content to readers. First - the article must be factually sound. Second - it should look appealing and be easy to read. We’ll focus on the latter.
How Information is Created?
Agnieszka Osińska
The media construct the world for us - the audience. However, most viewers, listeners, or readers do not have direct access to the issues discussed in the reports.