25.11.2024 Media market
Journalism and Technology. How Indian Newspapers Fight to Survive
KFi
The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the transformation of India's press industry. Traditional print media, forced to fight for survival, adopted modern technologies ranging from data analysis to artificial intelligence. How do journalists adapt to new roles, and how do media redefine their future in the digital age? Researchers from the Symbiosis Institute of Media & Communication have explored these questions.
Technological advancements have long shaped various aspects of social and economic life, and the media industry is no exception. In India, these changes accelerated due to the pandemic, which demanded faster adoption of new technologies and a transition to digital platforms. Journalists, editors, and entire media teams had to adapt to remote work, utilizing new tools like data analysis, visualization, and artificial intelligence (AI).
The detailed findings are captured in a report by researchers Dipannita Das and Ashwani Kumar Upadhyaya, researchers from the Symbiosis Institute of Media & Communication, published in Nature Humanities and Social Sciences Communications.
The authors used a qualitative approach, drawing on Labor Process Theory to analyze the relationship between technology and capital in the context of occupational shifts. The study included semi-structured interviews with 30 journalists and editors from major English-language newspapers in India, such as The Hindu and Times of India.
During the study, 100% of respondents recognized acquiring new technological skills as essential. Skills like data analysis, multimedia production, and online content management have become critical to daily work.
One of the most significant outcomes of technological transformation in the media industry is the rise of data journalism. Statistical analysis and visualization allow journalists to present complex topics in a simpler, more accessible manner. For instance, Associated Press implemented AI tools that increased the number of quarterly reports from 300 to 3,700, significantly improving production efficiency.
Statistics Highlighting Transformation:
- Decline in newspaper circulation: 2% in 2020.
- Growth in online media consumption: 123% during the same period.
- Reduction in print advertising revenue: from $2.74 billion in 2018–2019 to $1.2 billion in 2019–2020.
New Roles for Journalists in the Digital Newsroom
The pandemic forced journalists to change their work methods. Their roles evolved from traditional reporting to creating multimedia content, interacting with audiences on social media platforms, and optimizing materials for search engines and social media algorithms.
One of the main challenges is versatility. Journalists must now act as writers, photographers, and video creators, requiring not only extensive technical skills but also the ability to manage multiple tasks efficiently. Data shows that 93% of respondents had to master new digital tools to meet the demands of the new reality.
Comparison of Journalistic Skills Before and After Technological Transformation
Aspect | Traditional Journalist | Modern Journalist |
---|---|---|
Work Tools | Pen, typewriter | AI, digital platforms, apps |
Core Skills | Writing and reporting | Data analysis, storytelling, SEO |
Main Distribution Channels | Social media, websites |
Respondents emphasized that role changes required intensive training and continuous skill development. For instance, the ability to create videos and conduct live streams has become an essential part of daily work.
Challenges and New Business Models
The pandemic exposed the weaknesses of traditional print advertising-based revenue models. Print ad revenues in India plummeted, forcing publishers to seek new income sources. Subscription models, sponsored content, and online event organization have become essential elements of business strategies.
Data Illustrating Financial Challenges in the Sector:
- Paper costs increased by 20% in 2020.
- The print industry lost approximately $1.878 billion in the first eight months of the pandemic.
- The number of layoffs in the media sector exceeded 3 million nationwide.
Some publications, such as The Hindu and Mumbai Mirror, completely transitioned to digital formats, abandoning print editions. Others, like Indian Express, had to reduce the number of pages and limit the activities of local editions.
The Social Impact and Future of Media
Media transformation has influenced access to information but also revealed social inequalities. While over 751 million people in India have internet access, a significant portion of the population, particularly in rural areas, remains excluded from the digital revolution.
Key Data on Media Consumption in India:
- 72% of respondents used online news, but only 40% relied on print newspapers.
- TV and newspaper apps were the main sources of information for 86% of internet users.
Digital exclusion in India has a deep social and class dimension. Media increasingly focus on wealthier audiences, leading to the marginalization of poorer communities.
The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Newsrooms
AI in Indian journalism is still in its early stages but is already reshaping newsroom operations. Algorithms enable journalists to analyze trends, personalize content for audiences, and automate routine tasks like translation and text editing.
Examples of AI Applications:
- Quarterly report generation (e.g., by Associated Press).
- News personalization based on user preferences.
- Automatic translations into regional languages, enhancing information accessibility.
However, along with AI`s benefits, challenges emerge. Many journalists fear automation could lead to job losses. At the same time, they stress that the human aspect of journalism, such as interpreting events or empathy in reporting, remains irreplaceable.
The Future of Journalism in India
The Indian media sector faces many challenges but also enormous opportunities. The rise in internet users, the growth of regional digital platforms, and the implementation of new technologies create chances to reach wider audiences. At the same time, ensuring that digital transformation is inclusive and accessible to everyone, regardless of economic status or location, is crucial.
Journalists in India must not only adapt to the rapidly changing market but also act as guardians of truth in a world dominated by algorithms and misinformation.
About the Research
The report was authored by Dipannita Das and Ashwani Kumar Upadhyaya, researchers at the Symbiosis Institute of Media & Communication in India. The sample included professionals with over 15 years of experience who held managerial positions or were editorial leaders. Interviews were conducted remotely via phone, online chats, and email, providing an in-depth understanding of newsroom changes during the COVID-19 pandemic. The analysis included data coding and identifying four main themes: changes in journalistic roles, employee relations, technology`s impact on organizational structure, and publishing management strategies.
The findings, published in November 2024 in Nature Humanities and Social Sciences Communications:
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-024-04055-5
COMMERCIAL BREAK
See articles on a similar topic:
Future of Public Media. Who Will Be Data Ethicists and VR Designers?
KFi
How does the future of work in media look? Here are professions that do not yet exist but will soon become essential. The report "Future Jobs at PSM: Competencies and Professions for the Media of Tomorrow," prepared by the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) and Rai Ufficio Studi, outlines key changes awaiting the public media sector in the coming years.
Fake News in Poland. Challenges in Assessing Information Credibility
RINF
One in four information consumers relies on sources where verifying credibility is a significant challenge. Fake news remains a major issue, as indicated by 77% of respondents, with 51% admitting they struggle to discern truth from falsehood, according to Deloitte's *Digital Consumer Trends 2021* report.
Streaming Services. Rapid Growth of Subscribers in Poland
RINF
Compared to 2020, 20% more Poles declared having a subscription to video streaming services in 2021, according to the *Digital Consumer Trends 2021* report published by Deloitte.
Trust in Public Media in Europe. Report by the European Broadcasting Union
Krzysztof Fiedorek
Public media in Europe play a significant role in fostering trust and supporting democracy. The EBU 2024 report examines leaders, major challenges, and the impact of media on society. Polish, Hungarian, and Greek media, with results far below the average, face a crucial question: can trust be rebuilt?
YouTube vs. Television. The 50+ Generation Shifts to Computers
Krzysztof Fiedorek
For years, so-called "silvers" were primarily associated with traditional media like television. However, research by IQS for SilverTV and Lifetube shows that this view is outdated. The report’s findings clearly demonstrate that YouTube is becoming the new “television.”
"No One Should Know the Truth" [DOCUMENTARY FILM]
BARD
According to the Belarusian Association of Journalists, around 554 journalist detentions occurred in Belarus between August 2020 and July 2023. Criminal charges were brought against 73 media workers, and 33 of them remain in prison to this day.
Milgram Experiment 2023. AI Can Encourage Violence
KrzysztoF
Researchers from SWPS University replicated the famous Milgram experiment, in which participants were instructed to inflict pain on another person under the authority’s command. This time, the authority was a robot. It’s the first study showing that people are willing to harm another person when a robot commands them to do so.